What’s the Over/Under on Health FSAs and COBRA?

If you are a COBRA eligible employer (20 or more employees for 50% or more of the prior calendar year) and offer a Health Flexible Spending Account, that plan is subject to COBRA rules. In fact, it’s considered a group health plan, therefore treated just like a group medical plan…to a point. That point hinges on how much the participant has contributed to and been reimbursed from the account prior to terminating employment.

If an employee terminates employment (becoming a Qualified Beneficiary or QB) and underspent their Health FSA account, they become COBRA eligible and a COBRA notice is required. The QB can elect to pay premiums which will allow them to participate in the Health FSA after termination, just as they would for COBRA coverage on a medical plan.

It’s important to note that COBRA eligibility only applies to the Health FSA account. The Dependent Care FSA is not a COBRA eligible benefit.

When would COBRA for a Health FSA be offered to an ex-employee?

As mentioned, COBRA is offered when a QB underspent their Health FSA account. COBRA is not required to be offered when a QB overspent their account. How do you calculate whether a participant underspent vs. overspent?

Let’s look at some examples:

Annual election$2,400$2,400$2,400
Amount contributed at termination$1,200$1,200$1,200
Amount reimbursed before termination$800$1,800$1,200
Balance remaining$1,200 – $800 = +$400$1,200 – $1,800 = ($600)$1,200 – $1,200 = 0
COBRA eligible?Yes – the account is underspentNo – the account is overspentNo – the account is even

Oh, but you ask, what about a plan with a $500 carryover provision? We’ll get to that a bit later.

How is the Health FSA COBRA premium calculated?

The math is pretty simple. A Health FSA COBRA premium is 1/12 of the annually elected amount. COBRA law allows an additional 2% to be added to the Health FSA COBRA premium as an administrative fee.

So, using our QB1 example above:

Annual election: $2,400/12 = $200/mo.

Admin fee: $200 x 2% = $4

Max monthly COBRA premium: $200 + $4 = $204

Why would a terminated employee pay a COBRA premium for the Health FSA?

Again, looking at our example, QB1 contributed $1,200 and received only $800 in reimbursement. One month of COBRA premium ($204 paid with after-tax dollars) would allow the QB1 access not only to the $400 difference but also to the entire remaining amount of $1,200. Pretty good deal for the QB, right? But, there is some risk to the employer. After all, there is no requirement that the QB remain paying COBRA premiums month after month.

In a worst-case scenario, QB1 pays the $204 premium for one month, gains access to the remaining annual election ($1,200 in our example) and submits a claim for the whole darned amount. The employer has to pay it. That’s the deal with an FSA. The employer ultimately acts as an insurer. Sometimes they come out ahead, sometimes they don’t.

Is a COBRA FSA QB eligible for an extended grace period or $500 carryover for the following plan year?

Once a QB has paid the premium to the end of the current plan year, if the plan includes a 2.5 month extended grace period or $500 carryover, the COBRA participant is allowed to take advantage of those provisions. The employer can pass along any third party administration fees (same as are charged for Active participants) plus the 2% allowable COBRA fee to enable the QB to submit claims. 

Can a COBRA FSA QB continue to use their debit card?

While there isn’t a law about allowing/not allowing a debit card while on COBRA, at Sound Benefit Administration, an FSA participant who has terminated employment will not be able to use their Health FSA debit card beginning the day after they terminate. The primary reason is that we want to make sure that participant has paid their COBRA premiums before any more claims are processed – whether that be online, mobile app, emailed, faxed or mailed. Since COBRA participants have a 30-day grace period to pay premiums, Health FSA claims will not be considered until the COBRA premium for that month has been received in full.

Is a QB allowed 18 months of COBRA?

There is a special COBRA rule which limits COBRA participation in the Health FSA only to the end of the current FSA plan year. QBs are not permitted to enroll in the following plan year. However, as mentioned above, if the QB has paid COBRA premiums through the end of the current plan year then:

  • The QB is entitled to any grace period provided under the plan (see current year 2.5 extended grace period later in this article). 
  • Unused balances up to $500 are to be made available in following years (assuming the plan has a $500 carryover provision, see current year $500 carryover later in this article) up to the 18th and final month of COBRA.

What about the $500 Carryover from the prior year?

The math gets a little more complicated when we factor in a $500 carryover from the prior year. While the carryover from the prior year is NOT considered when calculating the COBRA monthly premium, it IS considered when determining if an account is under or overspent. Let’s look at our example again with the carryover:

Annual Election$2,400$2,400$2,400
Prior Year Carryover$500$500$500
Total benefit in current plan year$2,400 + $500 = $2,900$2,400 + $500 = $2,900$2,400 + $500 = $2,900
Amount contributed as of termination$1,200$1,200$1,200
Benefit for over/under calculation$2,900 – $1,200 = $1,700$2,900 – $1,200 = $1,700$2,900 – $1,200 = $1,700
Amount reimbursed before termination$800$1,800$1,200
COBRA eligibility?Yes – the account is underspent because the benefit ($1,700) is greater than reimbursements ($800)No – the account is overspent because reimbursements ($1,800) are greater than the benefit ($1,700)Yes – the account is underspent because the benefit ($1,700) is greater than reimbursements ($1,200)

You can see that by including the carryover from the prior year, QB3, who was COBRA ineligible in our first example, is now COBRA eligible with the carryover. This is because QB3 actually contributed that $500 in the prior year and is eligible to use that money in the current plan year for reimbursement.

What about the 2.5 month extended grace period?

If a Health FSA plan has a 2.5 month extended grace period provision, it allows participants to spend down unused balances of any amount for an additional 2.5 months after the end of the plan. QB’s are afforded the same rights as an Active employee, so if a QB has paid all COBRA premiums to the end of the current plan, they also have an additional 2.5 months to incur expenses to spend down an unused balance and an additional 60 or 90 day run-out period (as determined by the plan document) to submit claims.

I always like to tell people to think of an FSA more like a medical plan and less like a bank account (hello HSA…). Some participants will simply get more benefit than others. Employers may have to cover some losses. And, as is generally the case whenever COBRA is involved, you need to make sure you know the rules and nuances…or just remember to ask us.

We have a wealth of information on all topics FSA on our blog. It’s good reading!

Ways to stay informed

SBA’s Monthly Soup Scoop Newsletter. Please subscribe to Soup Scoop to have our most recent articles and information delivered to your inbox.

Follow us on Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter!



Like it? Share it!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin